well. i can say a bit more..
wow. it was sure terrible.
i really thought that i would be more amused just by the whole idea without regard to the actual implementation. at quakecon the snippets shown made it look ok. maybe it was the adrenaline from everyone else. i dunno.. i was just disappointed.
also, how many freak'n times did they say dr. carmack? 100? geez. i appreciate the nod, but you don't have to go that far.
speaking of nods.. i missed the very beginning, but what the hell is the deal with only putting.. based on the video game by idsoftware. where's the props for at the very least the id artists? i didn't see any mention of kenneth scott? he came up with the freak'n creature designs. surely hollywood can understand at least that aspect of our business.